| Caroline, you were a friend of mine | |
| Long ago when to err, it was divine | |
| You spoke your mind to all the guys | |
| They never knew if what you said was true. | |
| We started making sense | |
| We never made any sense | |
| We started making sense | |
| We never made any sense | |
| Caroline, all this once upon a time | |
| You would ask if you could still come back to me | |
| You run your mouth on crowded nights | |
| When the moon was high and then all at once. | |
| We started making sense | |
| We never made any sense | |
| We started making sense | |
| We never made any sense | |
| X 2 | |
| When you looked up it all fall in to silence | |
| No one lets a girl like you get bored | |
| We stopped making sense | |
| We never made any sense | |
| We started making sense | |
| We never made any sense | |
| We started making sense | |
| We never made any sense | |
| We started making sense | |
| We never made any sense | |
| We started making sense | |
| We never made any sense | |
| Oh, we stopped making sense. |