Never thought I'd ever be alone again Never thought you'd go and find yourself a new trend Should've known I was always in the dark with you Shared less words than even secrets do Plain This feeling's feeling plain Plain I always knew we'd be plain Plain This feeling's feeling plain Plain I always knew we'd be plain Did you ever even feel some kind of way 'Cause now when I look at you, yeah, I feel plain Our kisses never hot, never cold Thought you were the one, you were just her mold Wouldn't call it stale, wouldn't call it fresh Doesn't tip the scale, it ain't seasoned yet Wouldn't say it's good, wouldn't say it's bad But I guarantee you've already had it Plain This feeling's feeling plain Plain I always knew we'd be plain Plain This feeling's feeling plain Plain I always knew we'd be plain