| Song | Finale |
| Artist | Jesse Warner |
| Artist | Max Kennedy |
| Artist | Caroline Vickstrom |
| Artist | M. Shane Grant |
| Artist | Tyler Corcoran |
| Artist | Julia Jacobson |
| Artist | Justice Warner |
| Artist | Hayden Hensley |
| Artist | Lesley Shannon |
| Artist | Olivia Kisicki |
| Artist | Amanda Aurigemma |
| Artist | Oliver Strubbe |
| Artist | Annika Jacobson |
| Artist | Sarah Bach |
| Artist | Tahlia Knoshaug |
| Album | Man Up: A Musical (Original Cast Album) |